Is the project inside the sanctuary?
No. Official records put it about 15.5 km from the sanctuary and outside its eco-sensitive zone. But it is in the Western Ghats, on the same escarpment, and the project's own environmental report records leopards, sloth bears, pangolins and four-horned antelope here. Our concern is the Sahyadri forest itself, not just the sanctuary line.
Isn't pumped storage green energy?
Yes, it helps store solar and wind power, though about a quarter of the energy is lost in each cycle. Such plants can also use existing reservoirs, or "closed-loop" designs that don't dam a river. This project was in fact first proposed as closed-loop, and later redesigned to dam the Pej.
Won't new planting make up for it?
A sapling is not a forest. A hundred-year-old tree with its moss, orchids, fungi, nests and soil life takes decades, sometimes centuries, to come back. For this project, the compensatory land is about 150 km away in Patan taluka, Satara district, and it is already forested.
Is the 32,490 figure real?
Yes. The Forest Department confirms permission to fell 32,490 trees (14 Oct 2026). The company's own draft environmental report estimated about 48,000. Activists claim the real number is higher, but that is unverified. That gap is why we ask: publish the full tree-enumeration list.
Why the landslide risk?
In heavy rain, Sahyadri slopes are held together by tree roots. Disasters like Malin (2014) and Irshalwadi (2023) happened in this same range. Tunnel blasting and bare slopes can raise that risk, hence the call for an independent study.
Is this the only project here?
No. A second unit, Saidongar-2 (Maval), would share the same lower reservoir, and Tata Power's 1,800 MW Shirawta project is about 6 km away. That's why we ask for a cumulative-impact study.
What do the government and company say?
The government and Torrent say the project has every required clearance; that much of the plateau is scrub and grass with sparse trees (per the environmental report); that downstream drinking and irrigation water won't be affected (per a state hydrology certificate); and that it will avoid millions of tonnes of CO₂ a year compared with coal. Activists say the forest holds trees 200–300 years old. Only an independent survey can settle it.
What can I do?
1) Sign the petition below. 2) Email the ready-made letter. 3) Share this link in your WhatsApp groups. 4) Ask your MLA and MP about it. 5) Visit Bhimashankar, respectfully.